(1/2) Can I ask an honest question that I haven’t really seen any Gillovny believers talk about or explain? If you believe David and Gillian were together at least 2-3 years (this is how I think most days) them why the @#&! hadn’t David looked broken up and why hasn’t Gillian? I’m so confused. I noticed most Gillovny just switched their thinking and said Gillovny was never real, Gillian played us and Orlando wanted publicity. I don’t agree with that but I’m so confused. (more)

(2/2) I talked to my girlfriends and we all agree that when wet break up with our boyfriends (and some of us have had multiple year relationships) we show it and don’t go back to speaking warmly about our exes for years. We definitely wouldn’t want to work with them even if our sex was great. I’m so confused. Gillian’s fine. David’s fine. I’ve read people saying he let her go and he’s happy singing and writing but that’s dumb. He’s human not a robot. He’s got feelings. See why I’m SO confused?

–

That’s a really good question. That’s probably The Only Question. And I have no answer to that.
They were fine at The Webbies, but it was before Portofino, so I look forward to see them together now and make sure they’re still fine. David isn’t the kind of person you can easily read, so except if he looks like 2008-skinny-Duchovny, it’s hard to say in what mood he is. But I agree that if they’ve broken up, it should show at some point, especially when spending so many months together.
I think they will remain two professional, though, and try to separate their private life from their job, but either you believe they’ve broken up or they’ve never been together, I think we will observe a shift in their dynamic. Things have definitely changed a lot since the last time they filmed together and I’m pretty sure we’ll see that in their behavior in the next few weeks.