I was reading your reply to the Public Eye anon, and at one point I thought, okay, bye JHH, it’s been nice knowing you, but thankfully you then said you do not believe the theory that that thing with PM is OMG STAGED. But still you are willing to enterntain the possibility despite the fact that it contradicts basic common sense. And at the same time, you had denounced the idea that G&D might be FwB, and PM does not change much in their relationship. May I ask what are your reasons for that

I said all that in one post?

It’s not that I’m “willing to entertain the possibility”. It’s something that I’ve always said I thought was making sense, and especially after reading @altaircolin‘s posts about it. That would explain many things, and also, most of all, that’s what I want to be true. But I’m also a rational person, and I know that what I want to be true isn’t necessarily the truth. This theory is far-fetched, crazy, and sounds like Gillovny is one big conspiracy. And yet, I can’t totally shake it out of my mind so even if it’s a tiny part of me, this part has the hope that Gillovny will come out after xf and everything will be explained and all will be right in the world again.
On the other hand, that would also mean that Gillian went really really far to protect her relationship with David, and he would have had to accept more than any man on Earth could. That’s mostly the reason why I said I can’t wrap my brain around this theory, and probably why you think it contradicts common sense. It does. Okay. But what if? I believe she’s with PM for now (or was, haha!), but I still have a lot of what-if popping in my head, and I can’t push them back completely. 

As about David and Gillian being friends with benefits, that’s a theory I’ve always rejected and never made any sense for me, at least not in the new developments of Gillovny, and certainly not while she’s with PM. David is territorial as hell with Gillian, either you believe they’re together or not, he just is. I don’t see him sharing. I don’t see Gillian sharing either. And really, I don’t see PM sharing with anyone, and certainly not with David. There’s also so many kids involved in this trio, kids who know each other, that I don’t think this could work. And last but not least, I don’t believe in that kind of relationship in the long run. Not with them having such a complicated and intense background that we probably only know the tip on the iceberg of.