Do we all agree that the « if that were David she did those things with at the gg you would all say they’re together! » argument is one of the most laughable? We don’t need to hypothetically swap P for D because we have 24 years worth of actual heart eyes.

Most of all, I think this perpetual comparison between David and PM needs to stop. None of the relationship she had or has can be compared to the one she has with David. They’ve both been very vocal about how unique and unexplainable it is.

If you (it’s a general you, I don’t mean you, anon) believe she’s with PM and believe she’s never been with David, then you should compare her relationship with the official ones she had. With Clyde, Rodney, Julian or Mark, never we had any doubt she was in a relationship with them. It was crystal clear from day 1.
Wanting and needing to understand what’s going on with PM actually doesn’t have anything to do with wanting to prove or dismiss Gillovny, at least, it shouldn’t be the case. If you look at the way she was with her previous partners, husbands or lovers, there is something wrong with the way she behaves with PM. If not, we would all be on the same page, no matter who we want her to be with. There is something that doesn’t fit. It’s a fact. I just want to know what it is.