The thing is, I’m not really interested in knowing if he’s charming or not. He wasn’t with Gillian, but I don’t think he had to, if he is with when he he has a girlfriend, good for him, is he isn’t, that’s too bad, but I really don’t care. I’m not interesting in him.
Rationally, there was nothing in his behavior that showed he was with her. I don’t think he’s dating Gillian, so if it’s not in his nature, why would he even bother to try to be charming?